The following discloses material risks associated with purchasing, holding, transferring, and redeeming WTIC, a WTI-backed digital commodity token issued by Energy Substantiation Partners, LLC (“ESP,” “we,” or “us”). You should read this document in full and consult your own legal, tax, and financial advisors before purchasing WTIC. Purchasing WTIC is speculative, involves significant risk, and is not suitable for all purchasers. You may lose some or all of the value of your token.
The reference value of WTIC is designed to equate to the spot price of West Texas Intermediate (“WTI”) crude oil, which is derived from futures market prices. Crude oil prices are highly volatile and have historically moved sharply, including intraday and over multi-day periods, in response to factors outside ESP’s control, including:
WTI experienced trading at negative prices during the COVID-19 global pandemic (April 2020) and has experienced single-day moves in excess of 20%. The value of WTIC may decline rapidly and without warning. WTIC is not a hedge against inflation, currency debasement, or any other macroeconomic condition.
Secondary markets for WTIC may be limited, illiquid, or non-existent. There is no guarantee that any centralized or decentralized exchange, market maker, over-the-counter desk, or counterparty will provide quotes, accept orders, or execute trades in WTIC at any particular price, in any particular size, or at all. Liquidity may deteriorate or disappear during periods of market stress — precisely when you may most want to exit a position, causing volatility in prevailing trading prices.
Bid-ask spreads, slippage, and price impact may be material, particularly for larger transactions. You should not assume you will be able to sell WTIC promptly or at a price reasonably related to the underlying WTI reference price.
The physical WTI crude oil constituting the reserve backing WTIC remains in the possession of oil producers and other energy market participants as evidenced by energy receipts issued by them and deposited with ESP’s custodian, which holds the receipts for the benefit of the holders of WTIC. The energy receipts embody a bailment arrangement which imposes common law standards of care on the oil producers and energy market participants as bailees.
The energy receipts, custodians, audit and attestation cadence, and segregation arrangements applicable to the reserve are contained in the reserve and custody documentation, which is subject to change.
Whatever specific arrangements apply at a given time, custodial and reserve structures expose holders to risks including:
Holders of WTIC will have only a proportional undivided interest in the energy receipts held by ESP’s custodian for holders’ benefit, which creates complexity for recovery upon a custodian default or segregation failure. In the event of custodian failure or any of the above events, recovery of value may be delayed, partial, or unavailable, even if the energy receipts are legally segregated, and may depend on bankruptcy or receivership processes outside ESP’s control.
Any attestations or audits provided are point-in-time, are limited in scope to what the engaging firm has agreed to test, and do not guarantee future solvency, completeness, or accuracy. Auditors engaged to confirm the reserves of underlying WTI may engage in negligent and even fraudulent conduct leading to inaccurate verification of the underlying reserve.
WTIC is implemented as a smart-contract token on a public blockchain. Risks include:
The legal and regulatory framework governing tokenized commodities-backed digital tokens is unsettled and evolving in the United States and globally. Federal agencies (including the CFTC, SEC, FinCEN, OFAC, and the IRS), state regulators (including state money transmission and securities regulators), and foreign authorities have asserted, and may in the future assert, jurisdiction over tokenized commodity products in ways that affect WTIC’s legality, value, transferability, tax treatment, or availability in particular jurisdictions.
New legislation, rulemaking, enforcement actions, no-action positions, or judicial decisions could:
WTIC is not a “payment stablecoin” as defined under the GENIUS Act and is not eligible for any safe harbor or framework specific to payment stablecoins.
Redemption of WTIC — the process by which an eligible holder burns tokens in exchange for USDC, fiat, or, as elected by the redeeming holder, physical delivery — is subject to mechanics, eligibility, timing, fees, and operational limits set out in the applicable redemption documentation. Material considerations include:
ESP relies on third parties to operate the WTIC product, including oil suppliers and other market participants, custodians, banks, market makers, exchanges, oracle providers, smart-contract developers, auditors, and software vendors. Failure, insolvency, fraud, breach, sanctions designation, or termination by any of these counterparties could materially impair the value, redeemability, or availability of WTIC. ESP itself is a privately held company and is exposed to operational, business, financial, and key-personnel risk; ESP’s insolvency could result in significant or total loss to holders. In addition, while energy receipts held by ESP’s custodian evidence title to the underlying WTI that held as bailee by oil suppliers and other market participants and backs WTIC, recognition of ownership to the underlying WTI may rest on the interpretations of common law of the states within the U.S. where the WTI is located. The body of law applicable to tokenization and title to commodities underlying commodity backed tokens is not well developed and thus WTIC holders are subject legal uncertainty in cases where title to the underlying WTI is litigated. In addition, conflicts of law may arise between the jurisdiction in which a WTIC holder or ESP’s custodian is located and the jurisdiction in which the underlying WTI is located.
The bankruptcy or insolvency of an issuer of an energy receipt evidencing the underlying WTI may result in competing claims to the underlying WTI and such claims may be subordinate to claims of existing creditors, particularly where creditors’ benefit from security interests under collateral arrangements that confer priority.
WTI is located in particular fields and facilities owned and operated the issuers of energy receipts for specified quantities of underlying crude oil held as part of the reserve and may be experience loss from natural disasters, unforeseen casualties, contamination or hazardous waste transformation. The indemnity and loss sharing or shifting arrangements made by ESP with oil producers and other market participants may not be adequate to cover the losses experienced by such events which may impact the adequacy of the reserve of underlying WTI and the redemption value of WTIC.
Unlike a USD-pegged stablecoin, WTIC is not pegged to any fiat currency and offers no fixed or guaranteed value. Its reference value moves with the price of crude oil, the market price for which has at times undergone substantial fluctuation and may decline to zero. WTIC is not insured by the FDIC, SIPC, or any other government or private insurance scheme. No party guarantees any minimum redemption value, return, yield, or liquidity.
This document is a summary of material risks and is not exhaustive. Additional risks may apply, including risks that ESP does not currently anticipate or consider material.
Nothing in this document constitutes investment, legal, tax, or accounting advice. You should consult your own advisors. By purchasing WTIC you acknowledge that you have read, understood, and accepted these risks.